As the news began to spread about this dangerous exploit, security researchers began to notice similarities in the code to another exploit that the FBI utilized. One such security professional gave his analysis via Tweets, which are screen capped below:
The 2013 FBI code was able to decrypt user identities who visited child porn sites via Tor. It would then transmit non-proxy IP addresses, MAC addresses, and other data to a main server in an attempt to apprehend the criminals. While there has been no confirmation as to whether or not the FBI is involved in this new 0-day, it would not surprise me if that was the case. It is not uncommon knowledge that the authorities use cyber solutions that not only help catch dangerous people, but also open up normal citizens to dangerous hacks (see: the iPhone San Bernardino incident). Even if the FBI is not involved in this new exploit; its code was still used to create a dangerous and potentially catastrophic cyber incident.
I say “potentially” because, thanks to the due diligence of researchers and coders, patches have been released by both Firefox and Tor. As Tor pointed out in their patch notes, the security flaw has been utilized already by some malicious hackers, but the damage was not as great as it could have been.
This incident teaches us is that when it comes to cyber crime and cyber security, a set of standards must be adhered to. There are rules of engagement in war, and now that the FBI is playing with fire via exploits, there needs to be an updated rules of engagement in fighting the cyber war. Security experts want criminals brought to justice, but we also don’t want the rights of regular citizens compromised in the process.
Photo credit: wordfence, @TheWack0lian, Cliff